Envy: Extended Ideas

As I continued to explore the relationship between Pride and Envy, I found that my attention was too scattered to really find an idea I could follow wholeheartedly. Thus, I decided to focus on Envy, as I thought that it had the potential to let me go much more in debt into my research and exploration of ideas.

The more I began to brainstorm, the more I realised that Envy stemmed from a feeling of insecurity; so, in reality, Envy blooms where Pride has been taken away.

I’ve decided to keep this idea at the forefront of my mind as I start to refine my ideas so that I can relate this to the overall design of my potential character. Envy is hard to show on the outside, as it seems like a very private feeling, but I want to make sure that I find a way to really emphasise the character’s nature, even from an outside perspective.

Some of my initial ideas include:

  • using a mask
  • using disfigurement
  • small stature, low on the ground
  • idea of ‘luring victims’, inspired by research on Kitsune
  • fox-like features, inspired both by research on Kitsune, and knowledge of Kuma Lisa, a fox character in Bulgarian Folklore usually presented as a trickster

Research: Iago, ‘Othello’

Overview:

Iago is a character from Shakespeare’s ‘Othello’ who is very well known for being an envious and vengeful character. He is the one who orchestrates the main character, Othello’s, downfall, and it has been heavily implied within the text itself he did so because of his envy for Othello’s power and influence.

Quotes:

  • “I know my price, I am worth no worse a place.” : Act 1 Scene 1 – pride is very obvious from the beginning; sense of self-importance is high
  • “I am not what I am.” : Act 1 Scene 1 – Idea of deception is presented; Iago is putting up a front for Othello, but is in reality seeking his own goals; parody of Moses’ ‘I am what I am’ – Iago has a corrupting influence
  • “We cannot all be masters, nor all masters/ Cannot be followed.” : Act 1 Scene 1 – Iago sees himself as more worthy of power than anybody else; LINK TO SLIGHT GOD-LIKE POWER (manages to kill many people); Othello might be powerful, yet his followers (ie Iago) do not actually respect him because of it.
  • a wife for a wife” : Iago thinks Othello slept with Emilia (his wife); relates to idea of ‘an eye for an eye’

How Will This Help Me?

Iago’s position as Othello’s right-hand man directly relates to Beelzebub’s position as Satan’s in Paradise Lost. They are both hungry for power and revenge, only with one fundamental difference: whilst Iago craves to take away his own leader’s influence, Beelzebub wants to help his to defeat and rule over a common enemy.

I think that Iago’s deceitful nature links well with my exploration of Envy as a masked sin. During the play’s events, Iago is seen putting on a mask of loyalty to Othello countless of times, whilst sharing his plans for his downfall with the audience. This portrayal of Iago’s envy as a sly and mischievous fuel to his revenge further merges well with my exploration of foxes as an animalistic representation of Envy, as foxes are often seen as scheming characters in folklore.

(Source: Trewin, A., Shakespeare, W. and Euan Cook (2018). Othello. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press.)

Research: Arachne

Overview:

Arachne was a weaver who acquired such skill in her art that she ventured to challenge Athena, goddess of war, handicraft, and practical reason. Athena wove a tapestry depicting the gods in majesty, while that of Arachne showed their amorous adventures. Enraged at the perfection of her rival’s work (or, alternatively, offended by its subject matter), Athena tore it to pieces, and in despair Arachne hanged herself. But the goddess out of pity loosened the rope, which became a cobweb; Arachne herself was changed into a spider, whence the name of the zoological class to which spiders belong, Arachnida. Ovid’s Metamorphoses is the chief source of the story.”

(Source: Arachne | Greek mythology | Britannica. (2020). In: Encyclopædia Britannica. [online] Available at: https://www.britannica.com/topic/Arachne. )


“Arachne
 in Greek mythology was a weaver who challenged Athena and was consequently transformed into a spider. There are three versions of the myth.

One version has it that she was a shepherd’s daughter that was particularly skilled at weaving. Boasting about her skill, she infuriated Athena, who appeared and contested her. Athena weaved four scenes in which the gods punished those humans that considered themselves equal to gods and committed hubris; Arachne, on the other hand, weaved scenes in which gods abused humans. Arachne’s work was clearly better than Athena’s; the goddess even more enraged due to what the weaving depicted, threw Hecate’s potion onto Arachne, transforming her into a spider and condemning her to weave for eternity.

In a different version, at the challenge, Athena weaved the contest between herself and Poseidon over who the patron saint of Athens would be, while Arachne did a depiction of Zeus’ advances to various mortal women. Athena realised how skilled Arachne was, but wanted to teach her to be more humble and respect the gods. Touching Arachne’s forehead, the woman was filled with shame and hung herself. Athena brought her back to life and turned her into a spider, in order to let her weave all the time.

In the final version of the myth, Zeus was the judge in the contest between Arachne and Athena, and whoever lost would not be allowed to touch a spindle or the loom again. Athena won in this version, and Arachne was devastated that she could no longer weave. Out of pity, Athena transformed her into a spider, so she could continue weaving without having to break her oath.”

(Source: GreekMythology.com (2015). Arachne – Greek Mythology. [online] Greekmythology.com. Available at: https://www.greekmythology.com/Myths/Mortals/Arachne/arachne.html. )

How Will This Help Me?

Unlike Iago, who is the source of envy in ‘Othello’, Arachne could be potentially seen as the victim of somebody else’s envy. Athena is the one portrayed as envious of Arachne’s talent, so she destroys her creation and, consequently, indirectly kills Arachne (at least as a human; she then becomes a spider, which means she, essentially, died as a human).

This closely links with my drive to showcase Envy as a fuel for revenge and hurt; moreover, Arachne’s physical transformation merges nicely with my idea to include disfigurement as both a result and a motive for envy, once again implying that Envy is the result of Pride being taken away.

Research: Kitsune

Definition:

Kitsune (, キツネ, IPA: [ki̥tsɯꜜne] (listen)) in the literal sense is the Japanese word for fox. Foxes are a common subject of Japanese folklore; in English, kitsune refers to them in this context. Stories depict legendary foxes as intelligent beings and as possessing paranormal abilities that increase as they get older and wiser. According to Yōkai folklore, all foxes have the ability to shapeshift into human form. While some folktales speak of kitsune employing this ability to trick others – as foxes in folklore often do – other stories portray them as faithful guardians, friends, lovers, and wives.” (Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitsune)

“In all three cultures, the fox-spirit is mostly viewed as an evil creature . They were known to enjoy the company of humans for a variety of reasons that almost always end badly for the unfortunate individual who encounters one. The main reason a fox-spirit might search out a human was to suck away their life force or to even eat human flesh and thereby steal any powers that person might have along with all their memories, knowledge, and even their human form.” (Source: https://www.ancient-origins.net/myths-legends-asia/kitsune-0012027)

How Will This Help Me?

I believe the legend of Kitsunes fits my initial ideas for the sin of Envy quite well, as the premise of the tale is that the creatures prey on humans in both fox and human form to steal something from them.

In my own understanding, an envious person would be inclined to try and gain whatever it is they long after from the other person, so it be possible for me to use this concept in my own elaboration of the silhouette ideas I have.

Thus, I plan on using Kitsunes’ physical, as well as fictional, look to further develop Envy as a character.

Research: Lamias

Definition:

Lamia is an ancient demonic creature originating from Greek mythology. According to legend, this daemon was once a beautiful queen who ruled over Libya. Zeus, king of Olympus, was so intoxicated by her beauty that he took her as one of his many consorts. This caused his wife Hera to become jealous and, in her rage, she kills Lamia’s children and transforms Lamia herself into a monster who is cursed to feed on the blood of children.” (Source: https://monster.fandom.com/wiki/Lamia#:~:text=Another%20common%20interpretation%20of%20Lamia,popularized%20in%20modern%20fantasy%20media. )

‘Paradise Lost’, John Milton

Quotes about Pride:

  • “What reinforcements we may gain from hope,/ If not what resolution from despair.” – shows Satan’s immense will to regain control and power by rallying his fellow fallen angels
  • “To do aught good never will be our task,/ But ever to do ill our sole delight” – Satan’s pride was hurt, so he now seeks revenge on those who wronged him
  • “here condemned/ To waste eternal days in woe and pain?” – link to Revelation Bible – ‘And the great dragon was cast out, that old serpent, called the Devil, and Satan, which deceiveth the whole world: he was cast out into the earth, and his angels were cast out with him.’; more imagery of snakes!
  •  “Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven.” – cannot stand being inferior
  • “We may be reading the words of a devil, but also of a self-conscious tragic hero.” – commentary on Paradise Lost from Forsyth
  • “Stirred up with envy and revenge” – narrator’s depiction of Satan as he is first seen in Hell; clear link between the two Sins
  • “his pride/ Had cast him out of Heav’n” – Pride seen as a vice
  • “set himself in glory above his peers” – clear theme about Satan deeming himself superior
  • “Yet not for [those dire arms],/ Nor what the potent victor in his rage/ Can else inflict, do I repent or change” – Pride refuses to bend under pressure from others/ no compromise

Quotes about Envy:

  • “Balancing [Beelzebub’s] unbounded envy of God is his slavish, selfless devotion to his infernal chief, Satan.” – commentary on Paradise Lost from Baumlin
  • “Of course, Satan’s and Beelzebub’s relationship has further allegorical significance: they are as close to each other as the vice Envy is to Pride.” – commentary on Paradise Lost from Baumlin
  • “with iron scepter rule/ Us here, as with his golden those in Heav’n.” – emphasis on material; envy shown
  • “Seduce them to our party, that their God/ May prove their foe, and with repenting hand/ Abolish his own works.” – (Beelzebub talking about humans) ambitious mentality; if they cannot be God’s favourites, nobody can
  • “none higher sat” + “A pillar of state” + “Deliberation sat and public care” + “princely counsel” + “Majestic though in ruin” + “sage” + “With Atlantean shoulders fit to bear/ The weight of mightiest monarchies” – very attractive description of Beelzebub